State College High Student, and a History Teacher's Response

Please respond to the student's opinion piece and the teacher's response to it.  Please post your respond in at least 200 words by tomorrow morning at 7:00 a.m.

You may respond in any way you like, but some questions you might consider:

What do you think of the student's arguments?  Does she make any valid arguments at all?  Explain. What do you think of the teacher's response to the student's editorial?  Do you disagree with any of her response?  Why or why not?